Excellent Toner. I use these toners daily after cleansing my face and I really like the way this one smells and feels.

I had used an unscented Thayer witch hazel. I got 3 from Stirling. This one is fantastic. I'm not sure about shaving with menthol in my soap, but having it here is wonderful. This has just the right amount of menthol and I love the scent. It does not smell bad at all. It's strong enough that hangs around, which is exactly what I want. This is the best so far of the 3 I have tried.

I have sensitive skin, and this is perfect for me. It has everything I need in a post shave splash and everything I don't. this product has an amazing menthol kick to it, and I use it daily to tone my face. I use this with the Shave soap and it is great. The amount you get with it, and for the price and ingrediants it can't be beaten.

I love stirling witch hazels. This is no exception. Holy cow this is strong menthol however. Way more than the soap/balm. Feels identical to the glacial level of menthol. I either got a mislabeled bottle or they just wanted me to feel the arctic. Either way I still love stirling and will just use less next time.

Nice product, the scent goes away very fast. Menthol makes your face feels very refreshing, personally I’m using it after washing face & after shaving during summer time

So with this one the scent is hard to distinguish from the menthol. I can pick out sweet and fruity notes but the menthol dominates it. It's just witch hazel and I'm using menthol for a reason, so I'm fine with this. It does a great job feeling fresh and cool, and maybe the subtlety is a benefit if you are wanting *some* scent that keeps a low profile.

Nice lime scent and menthol cooling feel. Not overwhelming. Easy to pair with other general citrus soaps.

I don't really know how to describe the scent, but clean and citrusy are pretty close.
What really gets me is the cold burn you get from this lotion. When first applied the menthol aroma hits you but your skin takes a while to react to the product. When it does it is like WOW! It is an intense feeling that lasts several minutes. It leaves behind a nicely-toned face and the soothing effects of the aloe.

The scent seems to fade along with the menthol chill so it will not clash with a Stirling EDT very much if at all.

Highly recommend you try it!

Used this after shaving with MITA (glacial) soap. I'm a big fan of Witch Hazel, but am now an even bigger fan of Witch Hazel with Aloe and Menthol! This provided a great aftershave experience. The scent is wonderful sharp, clean and citrusy, and lasted awhile post shave. This felt fantastic on my skin as it cooled, hydrated my skin and left my face feeling clean. I'm a big fan of menthol as it provided a continuing cooling experience on a hot and humid Missouri day.

Love this splash! Nice clean feel post shave with no burn. Very nice menthol addition and the scent is very strong. Lasts a while and I also like to use this after every shower. Fresh clean scent with good face feel.

I love the MITA line of products and this product just proves that. Very cooling and refreshing on the face. I try to use Witch Hazel after every shave just because I love it. I do miss the glass bottles that they use to come in but you now get double the amount of witch hazel so no complaints. If you love the MITA soap, you will absolutely love this!!

10/10

This is one of my favorite Stirling scents. With so many great scents this one stands out for me. A very good blend of citrus and menthol which neither overwhelming the other. I have started getting just 100ml bottles so I have a variety of scents to choose from. I use these witch hazel and aloe mixes for all my facial needs. Great as an aftershave or even for a bedtime or morning cleansing routine. I have seen a significant change on my face especially pimples, witch (see what I did there? didja?) have practically disappeared altogether.

You cannot go wrong with the Stirling witch hazel and aloe line and there will be a scent or two that you will enjoy.

I love the scent and the menthol blast of this AS. This is great for summertime...no burn, icy cold for 10-15 minutes, and soothing witch hazel and aloe. Leaves a nice finish when dry.
Love it!

I love the scent and the menthol cooling effect, which is a bit delayed until that kicks in. Great face feel, moisturizing, cooling and soothing. I love all the Margaritas in the Arctic products and I have the balm, witch hazel, the aftershave splash and the bath soap. The scent is nice and citrusy and lasts a good while. This is one of my favorite Stirling scents. Everyone who likes citrus products and menthol should definitely have this in their rotation. Thanks for all the great products, Rod and Mandy!

I ordered this along with the matching shaving soap while I was on vacation in Florida and I really wish I had done so before my trip. The cooling methol in both products would have been very refreshing against the unseasonably hot, humid weather down there. It's not 'eye-watering-strong' like Fine Accoutrements Snake Bite aftershave, but strong enough to last a while. The margarita scent is sweet and citrusy and would have been appropriate too. While in Florida I used PAA 'The Beach' instead which was nice, but I'll definately use these two next time--or whenever it decides to warm up around here in Michigan.

Got this pretty recently in 250ml form. Based on scent profile and level of menthol, both nearly identical to the glacial lemon chill balm I have, I think I may have gotten a mislabeled bottle.

Either way, this is an excellent way to wrap up a citrusy shave. I love these witch hazel & aloe products. Wonderful mix of astringent and moisturizer, strength of scent and menthol are both right where I like them. Another excellent Stirling product.

All I can say was that I tried this product since I have enjoyed some of the other Sterling soaps and After Shave balms. I really liked the light scent, it was not overpowering and the coolness of the menthol was a different experience for me. My face felt clean and refreshed, I liked it.

I have never liked alcohol-based aftershaves; the burning feeling is just unpleasant. I do like to cool off my face after shaving, though, so I use non-alcohol-based products. Having used another brand of scented witch-hazel-based splashes, I was eager to try Stirling's versions. This Margaritas in the Arctic is a great combination of soothing and cooling. The scent is great but it doesn't overstay its welcome, while the cooling of the menthol actually does persist for a while.

Wow, didn't really know what to expect for this but I have to say this is truly great stuff. If you haven't already looked up the awesome properties of Witch Hazel and aloe I suggest you do so! It's great for the skin after a shave, locks it up tightly and makes it glow. There's a burn after you put it on but it's such an awesome burn, kind of like Sliding head down a glacier whilst getting repeatedly slapped in the face by snowmen who have lemons coated with Toothpaste in their hands......... Great product especially for oily skin types Now that I have it I don't know how I ever shaved without it.

I have never used no smelled witch hazel, but I thought I would get some to improve my shave. This smells really close to the Margarita soap, a bit more "Citrusy" due to witch Hazel. It tightens and freezes your skin while healing cuts and irritation. The smell disappears after it dries, so you can finish with a cologne or balm.

The Balm Smells exactly the same and the scent stays with you for hours.